回答

✨ ベストアンサー ✨

Writing "their reactions" would also be correct. Both choices are possible and correct English:

✅ When I saw their reaction, I thought...
✅ When I saw their reactions, I thought...

"their reaction" suggests that the reactions of the classmates were mostly similar. "their reactions" suggests that there may be some differences between the individual reactions.

この回答にコメントする
疑問は解決しましたか?