English
高中

ライティングの添削をお願いします。
アドバイスもらえると嬉しいです。

英検準1級過去問
<TOPIC> It is a good idea for local governments to build tourist sites, such as theme parks and museums?

<POINTS> Construction cost, Effect on local people, Spending by visitors, The environment

I think that it is not a bad idea for local governments to build tourist sites, such as theme parks and museums. I have two reasons to support that. First, building tourist sites would cost a lot. construction costs were came from citizen's tax, so local governments should use it for more important things, such as schools. Second, if local governments build a tourist sites, local people's effect would be bad. When visitors come to their town everyday, would be loud. Some people say that there is a benefit by visitors coming to our town and have fun. However, it is bad being loud. In conclusion, I believe that it is not a good idea for local governments to build tourist sites.

解答

すでに入っている回答で添削されているように、出だしと最後の意見が反対になっています。打ち間違い?ですかね?

その他の部分見ていきます。

4文目(construction costs〜)
動詞をwere came fromと書かれていますが、be動詞に一般動詞の過去形になっているので、come fromとするか、are fromがいいです。
citizen’s taxは市民税ですか? であれば、civil taxがあります。単に国民が払う税であれば、taxes paid by citizens
such as schoolsは間違いではありませんが、学校の具体的に何に使うのかも書くといいかもしれません。

5文目(Second,〜)
build a tourist sitesが単数か複数かわかりません。aを書くのであれば、siteの単数形で。
local people’s effectの文は、少し書き替えが必要です。
→it would have a bad effect on the local people. など

6文目(When visitors come〜)
カンマの後は主語が必要です。

7文目(Some people〜)
there is a benefitの文、byをfromに変える、代名詞のourはtheにかえる、haveはhavingに。
→from visitors coming to the town and having fun.

8文目(However〜)
it is bad being loudは内容に合わず、曖昧です。

Neko

書き直したのでもう一度添削をお願いします!
I think that it is a bad idea for local governments to build tourist sites, such as theme parks and museums. I have two reasons.

First, building tourist sites would cost a lot. Construction costs are from civil tax, so local governments should use it for more important things, such as schools.

Second, if local governments build tourist sites, it would have a bad effect on the local people. Some people say that there is a benefit from visitors coming to the town and having fun. however, if visitors made loud noises, all day long, local people can not sleep at night because of noises.

In conclusion, I consider that it is not a good idea for local governments to build tourist sites, such as theme parks and museums.

るぅ

良いと思います。
細かいところを見れば、2つ目の理由のパラグラフで、all day longの前にはカンマはいらないことと、can notは2つに分けずにcannotの1単語で書くのがいいです。

Neko

いつもいつも本当にありがとうございます!
なかなか準1級は難しくて苦戦中です・・・。

るぅ

準1級からハードルが上がりますよね。文法というよりは、語彙力と読解力を鍛えないといけないですね。

留言
您的問題解決了嗎?