解答

✨ 最佳解答 ✨

還記得之前講過具有連接詞功用的有誰嗎?就是連接詞、關代跟分詞。what雖然可以引導介接問句,或者當the thing which作複合關代,但是這裡兩個都不是,因為後面那句話已經是完整的,沒有地方在塞其他名詞進去了。也因此,這裡只能用和關代用法很像,但是又不完全一樣,而且有使用時機限制的「準關代」!
如果是what的話可以寫what is noticed recently "is" that the website has been removed...如此一來就可以讓what is noticed變成主詞,這樣就沒問題了。

Terry

再來是準關代的部分,準關代之所以叫準關代就在於它不完全等於關代,主要的差別有兩個。
1. 有先行詞的時候,這個先行詞必須有as/such/the same
例: He is as smart a man as ever lived.
例: I hope to use such easy ways as all of my students can understand.
例: I used to be confused with the same grammar as you are bewildered(困惑) by.
2. 注意第一點我特別強調「有先行詞」,代表他不一定會有先行詞但是如果是一般關代的話是一定會有先行詞的,而這就是他的第二個不同:As可以引導子句放在句首用來修飾後面的整句話,而上面的第20、21就都是這個用法。
例: As is beyond my expectation, Richard is admitted to NTU. 這句話如果用which也可以寫成Richard is admitted to NTU, which is beyond my expectation.換句話說,也就是把原本修飾前整句的which子句搬到最前面改成as子句。
但是這個文法中還有一個小小的例外,由於這個文法太常使用被動式了,所以As is Vpp中的is是可以省略的,就像是第21題中的As expected,照理來說後面那件事情應該是「被預期」所以應該用被動式,但是因為這個文法可以省略前面的be.V所以才會是看到的As expected

Terry

下面一樣給你一題試試看
Please choose the sentence both rational and grammatically correct.
(A) What has been discerned(察覺), Tom has a crush on Sue.
(B) Tom wants to go to the same university as Sue goes to.
(C) As it expected, Tom's resolution is snuffed out(吹熄) by his parents.
(D) This is the saddest news as Tom has ever heard of.

uqi

我覺得是B
但A也不太確定
還是不太知道what的用法,是跟which一樣只能是主詞嗎

(C)要改成As (is) expected 對嗎 ,或是Which is expected

(D)的話前面要有 as /such /the same (?

Terry

答案是B沒錯,不過要注意的是C選項不可以直接改成Which is expected唷~
因為which是一般的關代,他必須有「先行詞」,而既然他叫作先行詞,那他當然就要在關代前面,所以如果要用which的話就要把它搬到後面,變成Tom's resolution is snuffed out by his parents, which is expected.(詳見上面講解的第二個不同之處)

Terry

再來是what的用法,你可以用兩種方式來理解他
1. 引導間接問句
2. 複合關代=the thing which,如果以這個方法來理解的話,你可以把what想成「帶有先行詞的關代」
但不管是哪一個,他都是名詞的形式,所以他引導的子句就可以放在平時名詞會出現的地方(包含主詞、受詞以及補語)。
分別給三個例子
1. (主詞)What I want for my birthday is a toy.
2. (受詞)My father buys me what I want for my birthday.
3. (補語)A toy is what I want for my birthday.
這裡的what I want其實就是the thing which I want。
那麼說回來,我們在回來看看上面的第20題,如果寫what會變成What you may have noticed, the website has been removed because it contains too much violence.在這裡what既不是主詞也不是受詞也不是補語,他只是一個放在已經完整的句子the website has been removed because it contains too much violence前面的一個名詞,但是名詞照理來說是不可以自己獨立出來的,就像我們也不會寫My birthday, I want a toy.因為這個名詞不應該自己獨立在外面。
同樣的道理,上面的那句話What has been discerned, Tom has a crush on Sue.後面的子句Tom has a crush on Sue已經完整了,what既不是主詞,不是受詞,更不是補語,他又是一個單獨在外面的名詞,所以也不會是正確的。

Terry

再給你四句話,你覺得下面哪一個what的用法錯了呢?
A. What you gave me, I liked that gift.
B. What you gave me was a really nice gift.
C. I really liked what you gave me.
D. This news is what shocks me.
記得在判斷的時候要看看這個what子句引導的東西究竟是不是主詞/受詞/補語,如果不是的話那這個用法就不正確唷~

uqi

是A嗎🤔 是可以直接改成I like what you gave me 嗎

B.是主詞
C.受詞
D.補語
對嗎🤔🤔

Terry

沒錯唷~

uqi

看了好幾遍終於懂了😵😵謝謝你哇!🙇🏻‍♀️🙏🤩

留言
PromotionBanner
您的問題解決了嗎?