Question

わち

なんで2番だめなんですか？

“Are John and Mary still living in New York?"
“No, they (
66
ロ
) to Dallas.”
D are just moved
③ have just moved
2 had just moved
will just move
実電

基本時制

Answer 1

✨ ベストアンサー ✨

taka

なんで2番だめなんですか？　⇒　なぜなら、②had just moved(過去完了形) は、過去よりも前の時制を表すために、常に「過去を表す表現」がないと使われないからです。
【例】
〇 "I [thought](過去形) John and Mary [were living](過去進行形) in New York." "No, they had just moved to Dallas."
✕ "[Are] John and Mary still [living](現在進行形) in New York?" "No, they had just moved to Dallas."
〇 "[Are] John and Mary still [living](現在進行形) in New York?" "No, they have just moved(現在完了形) to Dallas."

参考にしてください。